News

Wrexham star surprisingly named as one of League One’s best players, it’s not who you think

Add as preferred source on Google

Wrexham, along with Birmingham City and Wycombe Wanderers, are aiming to win automatic promotion from League One but only two players from the three teams are among the top-10 highest-rated.

As is to be expected given their league position, a number of the Red Dragons players have impressed over the course of the 2024/25 campaign.

Sam Smith was compared to an Arsenal legend after he scored his winning goal versus Wycombe Wanderers last week.

He now has three goals for Wrexham and had already bagged 11 for Reading in the league before completing his winter switch.

Ollie Rathbone has earned praise for his constantly excellent display in the last few months.

However, neither Rathbone, Smith nor the likes of Max Cleworth and Ryan Barnett, are among the top-rated players in League One this term.

Eoghan O'Connell in action during Wrexham AFC v Shrewsbury Town FC in the Sky Bet League One clash.
Photo by James Baylis – AMA/Getty Images

Eoghan O’Connell among highest-rated League One players

Instead, the only Wrexham man to be named on the list is centre-back, Eoghan O’Connell.

The defender’s form has been patchy in 2024/25, with Parkinson urged to drop O’Connell ahead of their 1-1 draw with Birmingham City last month.

However, according to WhoScored, he’s been given an average rating of 7.34 in the league this term, putting him fourth in the top-10 list.

Surprisingly, Christoph Klarer is the only Birmingham man to make the list despite the Blues running away with the league. Wycombe, meanwhile, don’t even have one star included.

Player/TeamRating
Paudie O’Connor, Lincoln City7.55
Lloyd Jones, Charlton,7.52
Louie Barry, Stockport County7.42
Eoghan O’Connell, Wrexham7.34
Oliver Casey, Blackpool7.30
Christoph Klarer, Birmingham7.29
Michal Helik, Huddersfield7.27
Carl Piergianni, Stevenage7.26
Lewis Wing, Reading7.26
Albie Morgan, Blackpool7.26
Via WhoScored correct as of 21/03/2025
Wrexham v Wolverhampton Wanderers U21 - Bristol Street Motors Trophy
Photo by Jess Hornby/Getty Images

Who are the highest-rated Wrexham players

O’Connell is obviously the top-rated Wrexham player, while Lewis Brunt takes second place.

Callum Burton is technically third, though he has only played four matches this season.

Max Cleworth and Ollie Palmer then round out the top five, with Rathbone surprisingly low on the list, only just cracking the top 10.

PlayerRating
Eoghan O’Connell7.34
Lewis Brunt7.33
Callum Burton7.12
Max Cleworth7.06
Ollie Palmer7.01
Ryan Barnett6.95
Sam Smith6.93
James McClean6.92
George Dobson6.88
Oliver Rathbone6.87
Via WhoScored correct as of 21/03/2025

Paul Mullin is 30th on the overall list with a rating of 6.29, while Steven Fletcher is 18th with a 6.60 rating despite his seven goals this season.